Search

Olde Town Arvada's Newest Restaurants Are Its Oldest Buildings

When the crew gutting the old Arby's on Olde Wadsworth Boulevard tore into the ceiling in 2024, they didn't expect to find much. Then the drop ceiling came down and a domed ceiling appeared above it, fitted with more than fifty recessed can lights nobody had seen in decades. Behind a false wall was a slab of granite that had been covered up sometime in the 1980s. Neither had been touched in years. Both are now visible inside Bonfire Burritos, which opened in that same footprint on May 16, 2025.

That discovery is not an anomaly in Olde Town Arvada. It's the pattern. Walk the six-block core between Grandview Avenue and Olde Wadsworth Boulevard and nearly every address that feels new to you this year is actually the same building it was ten, forty, or a hundred years ago, wearing a different business. The district isn't growing by construction. It's growing by excavation, and once you notice it, you start reading every "new restaurant" headline in Arvada a little differently.

The Arby's Nobody Wanted to Demolish

Bonfire Burritos started as a food truck in Golden in 2013, the work of five high school friends: Ian Lanier, Raymond Pierandozzi, Matt King, Travis Toms, and Sky Schnautz. By 2024 the brand was ready to leave Golden for the first time, and it chose the shuttered Arby's across from Olde Town Arvada for its second location. The team took the 2,400-square-foot box down to the studs, converted the old parking lot on the west side into a family patio with astroturf and a kids' zone, and kept the discoveries from demo, the dome ceiling and the granite wall, as part of the finished space rather than covering them again.

The Arvada location made a deliberate choice the Golden original didn't: it dropped the lunch menu entirely and focuses only on breakfast, the thing the brand is best known for. Lines have wrapped the corner on weekend mornings since opening.

What's worth sitting with here isn't the burrito. It's the box. A fast food building built for a national chain, with a floor plan nobody designs for charm, turned out to have real bones once someone had a reason to look. Olde Town didn't get a new building. It got an old one, reread.

The Building That's Been Through Many Uses

If the Arby's story is one layer of reuse, the schoolhouse two blocks over has a history just as layered.

The site at 5660 Olde Wadsworth Boulevard started as a one-room wood-frame school in 1869, on land donated by B.F. Wadsworth. The brick building that stands there now replaced it in 1882. Arvada's growing population outgrew the schoolhouse by 1920, when Arvada High School opened, and the building sat empty only briefly before it became the town's first movie theater in January 1921. Admission was 25 cents for adults and 11 cents for kids. The theater ran through World War II and into the early 1950s, after which the building cycled through Anderson's Sporting Goods, the Covillo-Parker School of Ballet, and eventually a supply store and a music hall, with someone along the way covering the original facade entirely.

The Arvada Urban Renewal Authority bought the building in 2001 and spent 1.5 million dollars restoring it. Removing the later facade, the renovation team found a second, older one underneath, with a gap above the doorway where a cornerstone should have been. The cornerstone turned up in storage at the Arvada Center, kept for decades among the town's historical artifacts. AURA reunited it with the building it came from.

An Italian restaurant called DiCicco's became the first tenant after the restoration, though it used the schoolhouse room mainly for special events. In 2015, Scott Spears, who already owned the nearby sweet shop Scrumptious, purchased the building and opened School House Kitchen & Libations, leaning fully into the schoolhouse identity with benches built from old bus seats and menus styled after Pee-Chee folders. The restaurant now pours more than 2,000 whiskeys and passed its ten-year mark in February 2025, a milestone its longtime staff credit as much to the neighborhood as to the menu.

"I love the feeling of community, both inside the restaurant and throughout Olde Town Arvada," general manager Andy Busold said in an Arvada Press report, describing why he and kitchen manager Paula Hotaling have stayed since opening day.

One building. A school, a theater, a sporting goods store, a ballet studio, an Italian restaurant, and now a whiskey bar with a class photo's worth of local memory built into the walls.

The Tavern That Just Changed Hands, Again

According to Westword, a shorter version of the same story is playing out right now at 7427 Grandview Avenue, where the Grandview Tavern and Grill has operated since 2004. In April 2026, chef Jeremy Wolgamott took over as its new owner. Wolgamott had spent years as executive chef at Bistro Vendôme before leaving in late 2024 to chase a restaurant of his own built around Southern cooking. He looked everywhere between Littleton and Boulder before finding a space about a ten-minute walk from his house.

The new Grandview quietly opened in early April, then threw a grand reopening on April 18 with an all-you-can-eat crawfish boil, 150 pounds of crawfish shipped in from Louisiana for the occasion. The menu now runs a $20 hot plate lunch special until 3 p.m., a Southern tradition Wolgamott describes as ordering a protein and a couple of sides for a set price, the kind of thing you'd find at any bar and grill across the South. Fried rainbow trout, smoked chicken with Alabama-style white barbecue sauce, and a pickled shrimp salad rotate through, served with hushpuppies, cornbread, and coleslaw.

Wolgamott has said he wants to be the face of the place, out from behind the line talking to regulars, which is a small thing but it tracks with everything else in this district. The building didn't change. The name barely changed. What changed is who's standing in the kitchen and what they learned to cook somewhere else first.

Why the Buildings Don't Change

None of this is coincidence, and it isn't really about nostalgia either. Olde Town sits inside a designated historic district, and the city's own guidance for it is explicit that new development has to be sensitive to that history and built to fit the existing pedestrian-scaled fabric. That's a real constraint. It's much harder to tear down and start over here than it is a mile away, which means most of the growth in Olde Town has nowhere to go but into buildings that already exist.

The other half of the mechanism arrived with the pandemic. Olde Town closed several streets to car traffic to let restaurants expand into outdoor seating, the same emergency move a lot of downtowns made in 2020. Arvada made it permanent in 2021, adding real barriers at intersections and commissioning street murals instead of reopening to cars. That decision quietly created new square footage, patio space, without a single new building going up. It's the reason a repurposed Arby's parking lot can become a destination on its own merits, astroturf and all.

Put those two forces together and you get a district that adds inventory almost entirely through reinvention. The building stock is fixed. The businesses inside it are not.

What's on the Calendar This Fall

The same logic holds a few blocks north at the Arvada Center, which has staged theatre inside the same complex on Wadsworth Boulevard for more than fifty years. Its new 2026-2027 season opens September 25 with a Neil Simon romantic comedy, followed by a staging of Misery on October 3. The Center's History Museum is hosting a Red Cross blood drive on October 8 in between. Down in Olde Town proper, Trick or Treat Street returns on Friday, October 30, the neighborhood's long-running answer to trick-or-treating along a car-free Main Street.

None of that requires new construction either. It's a fixed venue running a fresh program, the same trade that's kept the schoolhouse relevant for a hundred and forty years.

If you live in Olde Town, this fall is worth walking slowly. Order the crawfish or the hot plate at Grandview. Sit under the dome ceiling nobody knew was there. Notice, next time someone tells you about the newest thing in Olde Town, that they're almost certainly describing an old address.

The Iannone Group tracks these shifts across Arvada, Boulder, and the Front Range because a neighborhood's daily rhythm, not just its price history, tells you what it's actually like to live there. If you're curious what your home in Arvada or Olde Town might be worth in today's market, The Iannone Group offers a complimentary, no-pressure valuation whenever you're ready to talk.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Your Journey Starts Here

At the Iannone Group, we believe real estate is more than transactions—it’s about building relationships, achieving goals, and creating futures. Whether you’re buying your first home, selling a cherished property, or exploring investment opportunities, we’re here to guide you with expertise and care.

CONTACT US

Follow Us On Instagram