Search

Who Gets Old Town Lafayette's Empty Bank Corner? Where the Public Road Deal Stands

At Public Road and Geneseo Street there's a nearly 9,000-square-foot former Chase Bank. It has been dark since 2024. Next to it, at 108 N. Public Road, is a 35-space surface lot that has served as free public parking for Old Town since 2016. Across Public Road, the block keeps adding places to eat. Remi's Cajun Creole Cafe opened this summer at 211 N. Public Road. Teocalli Cocina has been at 103 N. Public Road since 2019.

Over the past year the bank building turned into a public decision. The city of Lafayette bought it, which put the choice of what moves in with the city. Residents then ranked three proposals, and two came from businesses already operating on these blocks. The top-ranked pitch came from The Read Queen Bookstore & Cafe, which currently operates about a block off Public Road at 129 N. Harrison Ave.

Why a city bought a bank

The purchase started with the parking lot. The Daily Camera reported in September 2025 that the Lafayette Urban Renewal Authority had leased the 108 N. Public Road lot since 2016 and wanted to buy it. When Chase announced in 2024 that it was leaving, the authority tried to buy only the lot. Chase said the two parcels would sell together.

Chase listed the pair for $2.7 million. The city's $2.6 million letter of intent was preliminarily accepted, and City Council approved the deal unanimously on Sept. 2, 2025. "I just want to say I'm very excited about this purchase," Mayor Pro Tem Brian Wong said before the vote, according to the Camera. City staff called the building a "strategic purchase" that could bring in a business that generates sales tax. They said the former bank had room for "adaptive reuse," possibly including more parking and a street patio.

After the sale, the two parcels went separate ways. The June 2026 Daily Camera report says the urban renewal authority paid the city back $1 million for the lot. The lot stays city-owned and open for public use, including the Lafayette Farmers Market and seasonal pop-ups. The city then offered the bank building for sale at $1.6 million.

The numbers line up. Take the $1 million reimbursement off the roughly $2.6 million the city paid for both parcels and you get $1.6 million, the same as the building's asking price. Public Road keeps its 35 public spaces either way, and whoever buys the building takes on the rest of the cost.

Three pitches, and the bookstore ranked first

Three groups bid for the building. The city presented them to residents through a Lafayette Listens survey that ran through early July. Respondents watched a short video from each applicant and then answered questions.

  • A community restaurant and beer garden from Grant Hopfenspirger, owner of Teocalli Cocina. He opened his first location a few doors down at 103 N. Public Road and has since added locations in Arvada, Longmont and Denver.
  • A four-way split from The Arts Hub and Urban West Group. It called for a restaurant and bar, two local retail spaces, and an underground black box theater and gallery for Lafayette's Arts Hub.
  • A move and expansion for The Read Queen Bookstore & Cafe, which Barbra Huntting and Deirdre Appelhans opened during the COVID-19 pandemic.

About 1,800 people responded, Lafayette Economic Development Director Brigid Keating told City Council. The Read Queen received the most support. Keating said the proposal reused an existing building and helped a local business grow. "Small business support and retention is key," she said, as reported by the Daily Camera.

Two of the three bidders already run businesses within a short walk of the bank, and the third would have given space to a Lafayette arts group. The survey asked which neighbor should grow into the corner.

What the bookstore says it needs the room for

The Read Queen has been at 129 N. Harrison Ave. for six years. The owners say they have outgrown it, and Huntting framed the move as a matter of space when she spoke to Council, according to the Daily Camera:

"This amazing community has supported us for six years, and we just keep growing and growing, and we've outgrown our space. We try to hold these events, these gatherings, these book clubs and programming, but we just don't have the space for it right now. We're bursting at the seams, basically."

According to the city's project page, the proposal calls for a flagship store with more retail space, community event space, outdoor gathering areas and "an active, year-round destination." That would put a bookstore, its events and outdoor space right next to a public lot the city has set aside for markets and pop-ups. A business that hosts book clubs and events, beside a lot reserved for community gatherings, gives this end of Public Road a reason for foot traffic on days the farmers market isn't running.

The store also brings local credibility. In March 2026, Huntting and Appelhans received the Lafayette Chamber of Commerce's Community Impact Award, as Colorado Hometown Weekly reported.

The deal is still being negotiated

Council has approved talks. It has not approved a sale. Here is the timeline so far:

  1. Sept. 2, 2025: Council approves buying 200 and 108 N. Public Road from JPMorgan Chase.
  2. June to early July 2026: The public survey on the three proposals is open.
  3. Aug. 4, 2026: Council authorizes staff to begin negotiations with The Read Queen, the top-ranked proposal.
  4. Next: In its own words, the city says "Staff and the Read Queen are working through negotiations now and will return to Council with a Purchase and Sales Agreement this fall."

The Oct. 20, 2026 City Council agenda did not include that agreement. No sale price, closing date or move-in date has been made public. The $1.6 million figure was the offering price in the city's brochure, not an agreed price. In August, Keating said the city expected negotiations to succeed. If they do, Council will take up a purchase and sale agreement at a later meeting.

The storefront on Harrison

If the move goes ahead, it frees up a space with its own following. Kurt Munding, who owns the bookstore's current building, backed the move at the August meeting. "They've been our favorite tenant we've ever had," he said, as reported by the Daily Camera. He said the bookstore will leave "big shoes to fill" and that he is glad it is staying in Lafayette. No new tenant for 129 N. Harrison Ave. has been announced. The bookstore and the side-street storefront it would leave open up at roughly the same time.

Local operators, existing buildings

The same pattern shows up within walking distance of the corner. Three of this year's openings in Lafayette took over existing spaces.

Remi's Cajun Creole Cafe, at 211 N. Public Road, is a 60-seat restaurant with Cajun and Creole food, cocktails and live music. Owner Dara Sanchez-Mack runs it, and Napoleon Lewis leads the kitchen, according to Axios Boulder.

Bee's Thai Kitchen has been one of Boulder County's well-known food trucks since 2021. It now has a dining room in a historic storefront on Simpson Street, east of South Public Road. As The Boulder Reporting Lab described it, Bee Kisich still cooks in the parked truck. The old building can't support a water line for a dishwasher, so meals come on paper plates. There is no liquor license, so diners who want a beer with their curry are told to carry their food a block to Odd13 Brewing's tasting room. Bee and her husband Kevin settled in Lafayette after meeting in Thailand. Kevin built the wooden slab tables in the front room. "This is a real ma-and-pa neighborhood eatery," he told the newsletter.

Pegasus Coffeehouse opened in October at 1280 Centaur Village Drive, in the former MeCo Coffee Collective space near Waneka Lake. The Daily Camera reported that owners Marc Gacy and Sonja Toutenhoofd spotted the empty shop in May while walking from their home a few blocks away. They opened less than six months later and plan to move past a soft opening in the coming weeks. "It has been a dream from when we were in our 20s that we would run a coffee shop, bookstore, or something like that," Toutenhoofd said. They are subleasing from MeCo for two years and then have the option to lease directly from the property owner.

Each of these openings moved into a building or storefront that was already standing. The bank sale at Public and Geneseo follows the same pattern on a larger scale, with the city buying the building and residents helping choose the operator.

This winter on the corner

Old Town Lafayette listed Oct. 25 as the last date of the Lafayette Farmers Market's 2026 season, which ran on Sundays from May through October on Public Road between Cleveland and Geneseo. Until a sale closes, the bank building at the Geneseo end of that stretch stays empty and the lot next to it stays public parking. The city has said the purchase and sale agreement will go to Council this fall. When it does, it will show up on the City Council agendas page with the price and terms that have been missing since August.

When a vacant corner gets a new tenant, nearby blocks feel it. Foot traffic changes, people's sense of the block changes, and in time so does the value of the homes within walking distance. If you own near Old Town and want to know what a revived Public Road corner could mean for your property, The Iannone Group can walk you through it. Request a complimentary home valuation, and we'll put your home's numbers in the context of what's changing a few blocks away.

Your Journey Starts Here

At the Iannone Group, we believe real estate is more than transactions—it’s about building relationships, achieving goals, and creating futures. Whether you’re buying your first home, selling a cherished property, or exploring investment opportunities, we’re here to guide you with expertise and care.

CONTACT US

Follow Us On Instagram